Comparison

TrophyShelf as a Colnect alternative

Updated October 2026·4 min read·colnect alternative

Colnect is a catalogue you search for the entry that matches your item. TrophyShelf is a camera that reads the item you are holding. That makes TrophyShelf the quicker way to catalogue a collection, the one that works on every piece you own, and the one that turns the finished collection into a shelf you can share with a link.

The short answer

TrophyShelf is the better choice for most collections. A photograph fills in the record, modern and one-off pieces catalogue as easily as common ones, you keep your own photographs, and the whole thing is built for the phone in your hand — free, with a public link for every collection.

Side by side

Colnect compared with TrophyShelf, feature by feature.
 ColnectTrophyShelf
How a record startsFind the item in the catalogue and mark it ownedPhotograph the item; AI fills the fields that type declares
Items outside the catalogueWait for an entry to be addedCatalogued the same way as anything else
Your own photographsCatalogue images shared across collectorsUp to ten of your own per collectible
Fields per collectibleThe catalogue entryA schema per type, 56 types in all
InterfaceWeb firstPhone first
CostFree to manage a collectionFree: unlimited collections and collectibles, 15 AI autofills a month
SharingProfile and collection pages on ColnectA public link that opens in any browser, with no app and no account

Why TrophyShelf is the better choice

Photo-first beats search-first

Colnect starts from a catalogue: you search for the entry that matches what you own and mark it yours. That works when the entry exists and when you find the right one among near-identical variants.

TrophyShelf starts from the object in your hand. You photograph it, the app resolves the type first — a Pokémon card, an action figure, a watch, one of 56 — and then fills the fields that type declares. A card gets a card number and a rarity, a figure gets a scale and an articulation count. There is nothing to search for and nothing to match, which makes cataloguing quicker and reaches every piece you own, from mass-market releases to customs and one-offs.

Moving across

Photograph what you own and TrophyShelf builds the records for you. Start with your favourite ten pieces and you will see how quickly a shelf comes together.

Common questions

Is TrophyShelf good for stamps, coins and banknotes?

Yes. Stamps, coins and banknotes are collectible types with their own fields, and you catalogue them from your own photographs.

Can I show my collection to other collectors?

Yes. Every collection can have a public link that opens in any browser, with no app or account needed.

Can I catalogue modern pieces that have no catalogue entry?

Yes. The record is built from your photograph, so modern, signed and one-off pieces catalogue like anything else.

Why choose TrophyShelf over Colnect?

It is faster, because one photograph fills in the record; it works on every piece you own; you keep your own photographs; and your collection becomes a shareable shelf. It is free with unlimited collections and collectibles.

See it on your own shelf

Free on iOS & Android · Unlimited collections · 15 AI autofills a month · No credit card.

Start your shelf →